Skip to main content

Programming instead of Neural Networks

Programming instead of Neural Networks

Overview

Project pivot discussion for the Digital Education project (Group: Kyoto baby) exploring switching the focus from neural networks to teaching programming / algorithmic logic to novice learners.


Meeting Notes & Decisions

1. Scope & Course Constraints

  • TA Validation Check (Urgent): Confirm with the TA (Dominique) whether the programming scope is sufficiently technical and acceptable. (Precedent: an AI project teaching foreign languages was previously rejected for being "too broad").
  • Pre-Validation Strategy: Submit an early draft to the TA via email ahead of the official deadline to get early feedback/green light, as the group feels ~2 weeks behind.

2. Key Benefits

  • Significantly easier recruitment: Vastly larger pool of prospective novice participants across EPFL and UNIL.
  • Funding & Publication Pathway: Opportunity for external project funding from a business project; professor is on board to turn this into a research publication (targeting a conference in Kyoto).

3. Risks & Pedagogical Focus

  • Scope Management: Must constrain the learning objective—focusing on intuitive algorithmic logic rather than heavy syntax overhead.
  • Baseline Confound: High variability in self-reported programming skills.

Experimental Protocol Design

  • Study Format: Between-subjects design.
  • Target Audience: Strictly novice / beginner programmers (screened).
  • Pre-Test / Screening: Include an objective baseline screening test/survey prior to the experiment (do not rely on subjective self-reporting).
  • Participant Session Budget:
    • ~1h15m – 1h30m per participant (1 hour task/training + 15–30 min pre-test, post-test questionnaire & debrief).
    • Cohort Size: ~20 participants total.
    • Time Commitment: ~30 hours total (~2 full testing days per team member, accounting for cancellations/rescheduling). Remote logging remains a secondary backup option.

Participant Recruitment Pipeline

  1. EPFL Bachelor Students: Request Mauro Cherubini to send study call to students in Éléments de programmation.
  2. UNIL Cohort: Reach out via 3 friendly UNIL professors (Michalis, Mauro + Yash maybe?) to broadcast to students.

Deadlines & Next Steps

  • This Week: Prepare a concise 1-page project proposal (hypotheses, independent/dependent variables, measurement metrics) for Mauro and the TA.
  • TA Pre-check: Email the 1-pager to Dominique / TA for early clearance before the milestone.
  • Milestone 1 Submission: October 8th (Official validation of project idea).
  • Design Screening Instrument: Create the short pre-test quiz to filter true novices.